Home > Bottled Water vs Filtered Water
Cost Comparison
| Type | Cost per Gallon | Annual Cost (1 gal/day) |
|---|
| Premium bottled (Evian, Fiji) | $4-8 | $1,460-2,920 |
| Standard bottled (store brand) | $1-2 | $365-730 |
| 5-gallon jug delivery | $0.80-1.50 | $292-548 |
| Filter pitcher (Brita) | $0.20-0.30 | $73-110 |
| Under-sink RO | $0.05-0.10 | $18-37 |
| Whole-house carbon | $0.02-0.05 | $7-18 |
Bottom Line: Filtered water costs 90-99% less than bottled water. A $300 RO system pays for itself in 2-6 months compared to buying bottled water.
Quality Comparison
Contrary to popular belief, bottled water is often just filtered tap water. The NRDC found that approximately 25% of bottled water is simply repackaged municipal water. The FDA regulates bottled water, but enforcement is less stringent than EPA tap water regulation.
| Factor | Bottled Water | Filtered Tap Water |
|---|
| Regulator | FDA | EPA + you choose filter |
| Testing frequency | Less frequent | Municipal: continuous |
| Plastic contamination | Microplastics common | None (if filtered) |
| Freshness | Sits in plastic for months | Fresh from tap |
| Contaminant control | You don't choose | You select filter for your water |
Environmental Impact
| Impact | Bottled Water | Filtered Water |
|---|
| Plastic waste | 50+ billion bottles/year (US) | Minimal (filter cartridges) |
| Carbon footprint | High (transport, manufacturing) | Very low |
| Water waste | 3L water per 1L bottled | RO: 3-4L per 1L filtered |
| Recyclability | Only ~30% recycled | Cartridges: some recyclable |
Switching from bottled water to a filter pitcher prevents approximately 1,460 plastic bottles from entering the waste stream per year (based on 1 gallon/day consumption).
Convenience Comparison
- Bottled: Ready to drink, portable, no maintenance. But heavy to carry, takes storage space, can run out.
- Pitcher: Always available, fills automatically. But needs refilling, takes fridge space.
- Faucet filter: Instant on demand. But may slow flow, needs filter changes.
- Under-sink RO: Dedicated faucet, always available. But requires installation and maintenance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is bottled water safer than filtered tap water?Not necessarily. Municipal tap water in the US is tested more frequently than bottled water. A quality NSF-certified filter makes tap water equally safe at a fraction of the cost.
Why does bottled water taste different?Taste differences come from mineral content and dissolved gases, not purity. Some people prefer the taste of certain bottled waters. Remineralization filters can achieve similar taste profiles.
Is it worth buying bottled water for emergencies?Yes. Store 1 gallon per person per day for at least 3 days. But also invest in a gravity filter (Berkey) for long-term emergency water supply.
Can I use bottled water in my coffee maker?You can, but it's expensive and unnecessary. Filtered tap water makes equally good coffee. If your water is very hard, use filtered water and descale regularly.
Affiliate Disclosure: Filter Tested participates in the Amazon Associates program. We earn a commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you.